Assigned to APPROP                                                                                                             FOR COMMITTEE

 


 

 

 


ARIZONA STATE SENATE

Fifty-Fifth Legislature, Second Regular Session

 

REVISED

FACT SHEET FOR h.b. 2323

 

homeowner's insurance; dogs; nondiscrimination

Purpose

Prohibits a dog's breed from being considered or used for prescribed purposes relating to a homeowner's or renter's insurance policy (insurance policy).

Background

The owner of a dog which bites a person in a public place or lawfully on a private place is liable for damages suffered by the person bitten (A.R.S. § 11-1025). A person is lawfully in or on private property of a dog owner if the person is an invitee, guest or when a person is performing a duty imposed on the person by U.S. or state law (A.R.S. § 11-1026). Proof of provocation of attack by a person injured by a dog is an authorized defense to an action for damages and must be determined by whether a reasonable person would expect that the conduct or circumstances would likely provoke a dog (A.R.S. § 11-1027).

Insurance is a contract by which a person undertakes to indemnify another or to pay a specified amount on determinable contingencies (A.R.S. § 20-103).

There is no anticipated fiscal impact to the state General Fund associated with this legislation.

Provisions

1.   Prohibits a dog's breed from being considered or used for:

a)   underwriting or actuarial processes for determining risk, liability, actual or potential losses or any other matter related to claims involving dogs under an insurance policy;

b)   questionnaires, surveys or other means of gathering information regarding ownership, possession or the presence of a dog on the premises under an insurance policy; and

c)   findings of fact or conclusions of law by a legal decision maker regarding whether a dog is aggressive, vicious or has caused liability to occur as part of determining coverage, liability or damages related to an insurance policy.

2.   Defines aggressive as a dog that has bitten a person or domestic animal without provocation or has a history of biting persons or domestic animals without provocation.

3.   Defines breed as a dog's actual, perceived breed or mixture of breeds.

4.   Defines policy of insurance as a homeowner's or renter's policy of insurance.

5.   Defines provocation as tormenting, attacking or inciting a dog and includes the standard for determining provocation by whether a reasonable person would have expected that the conduct or circumstances would have provoked a dog.

6.   Defines vicious as a dog that:

a)   has a propensity to attack, cause injury to or otherwise endanger the safety of persons without provocation; or

b)   was found to have any of these traits after a hearing before a court of competent jurisdiction or before a hearing officer.

7.   Becomes effective on the general effective date.

Revisions

· Adds a fiscal impact statement.

House Action

COM               1/31/22      W/D

GE                   2/16/22      DP     10-3-0-0

3rd Read          3/17/22                 42-16-2

Prepared by Senate Research

April 29, 2022

LMM/IJ/sr/slp